Council seeks answers after clearing along Russell’s bike path

When Cindy Saucier lived beside the New York Central Recreational Trail her friend brought her a jar of blackcurrant jam every year. People picked berries along a stretch of the trail Saucier and other volunteers had planted.
So the news hit hard when her friends started telling her that Hydro One had wiped out 13 years of community work, clearing vegetation north of the trail west of Eadie Road.
The crews still had some distance to go when The Rustler visited on Nov. 18. From their position past Keith M. Boyd Park east to Eadie Road, there was not a single living plant left.
“It’s a bit of a slap in the face,” Saucier recalled someone telling her in recent days.

The former township councillor, who now lives in Morrisburg, helped found Trees for Tomorrow. The local volunteer group grew out of the township’s environmental advisory committee around 2012 and took on the trail planting as one of its first projects. It organized the 2014 planting along the trail. Twelve years ago, Russell Township council voted to support that work. Saucier says the clearing took out trees, shrubs and native flowers that volunteers had put back after an earlier round of cutting. She wants the trail replanted.
The planting grew out of the township’s environmental advisory committee where Saucier served as vice chair and then councillor Eric Bazinet was chair. At the Living Locally Fair in January 2013 the tree committee raised $65 toward its planting work. The photograph in The Villager that month shows Saucier, Bazinet, biologist Steve Mihok, and then Mayor J.P. St. Pierre holding the first $20 donation.
In February 2014 Trees for Tomorrow asked Tree Canada to help plant a two kilometre section between Concession Street and Eadie Road. The proposal described a sunny strip of mostly loam over clay which was wide enough for volunteers to plant and for a vehicle to bring water if the seedlings needed it. It called for mostly native trees and shrubs that would bear fruit, berries or nuts for people and wildlife. Council backed the project on Feb. 18 and approved an estimated $1,200 toward costs not covered elsewhere.
The volunteers came with shovels on Saturday, May 10, 2014 and in a letter published 12 days later in Le Reflet, Saucier put their number at about 50. The Russell and District Horticultural Society took charge of the display garden at the trail entrance, while students and the Russell Scouts helped plant and the Embrun Richelieu Club fed the workers. In her letter, Saucier also thanked Ann Jackson of St. Thomas Aquinas Catholic High School and credited Tree Canada, its sponsors Loblaws, Silk and Telus, and Russell Township with helping fund the project. Saucier thanked Hydro One for donating mulch and for allowing low growing berry bushes and trees to be planted.
Saucier recalls volunteers planting more than 100 trees and shrubs. They mulched and weeded and one resident even bought them a wheelbarrow. Even Mayor J.P. St. Pierre came to dig, Saucier recalled.
She remembers elderberries, highbush cranberries and blackcurrants, as well as milkweed for butterflies and black eyed Susans. She says master gardeners from the Russell & District Horticultural Society and Marcel Beauchamp, who worked at the Dominion Arboretum at the Central Experimental Farm, helped choose low growing plants with the power lines in mind. In her letter, Saucier also thanked Owen Clarkin of the Citizens’ Environmental Stewardship Association East of Ottawa for his expertise. Saucier said Hydro One previously cleared vegetation on the trail and volunteers had to do some replanting.
Saucier now lives in Morrisburg and did not see the crews at work but her former neighbours along the trail were horrified.
“One of them told me that they ran out there and said, ‘What are you doing?’” Saucier said.
The clearing came up briefly at Russell Township council on Monday. Mayor Mike Tarnowski said the matter had been moved to the Nov. 23 meeting so township staff could prepare a report on what happened.
During a discussion about protecting natural areas, Coun. Charles Armstrong said he had received “numerous” emails about the clearing along the hydro right of way beside Russell’s bike path.
“We can’t forbid them if they decide to just roll down their, uh, their right of way within the limits of their right of way, of course,” Armstrong said.
Complaints also reached the office of Glengarry–Prescott–Russell MPP Stéphane Sarrazin. Emily Sabourin, who works in Sarrazin’s Hawkesbury constituency office, confirmed the office had received many complaints and forwarded them to Hydro One. She said Hydro One told them it was responding to each complaint but did not tell Sarrazin’s office why so much vegetation had been cut down.
Before the cutting Russell Township issued a notice saying that the New York Central Recreational Trail would be closed from the Mother Teresa School entrance to Eadie Road from Oct. 26 to Nov. 6 “to allow Hydro One forestry maintenance work to be completed safely within the hydro corridor.”

The Rustler asked Hydro One Nov. 18 what instructions crews received, whether the township or volunteers were consulted, and whether the utility would pay for restoration. Its media relations office responded that the earliest it could provide a written response was the end of day Thursday.
Saucier would start by restoring the planting along the trail. She also suggested planting 100 trees elsewhere in the township or contributing to Eco East, a local environmental group that works on projects such as native planting and community gardens, to plant them. Buying new plants, she said, would cover only part of what it took to establish them.
“It’s hard to put a monetary value on the hours that volunteers put in,” she said.
On Sept. 1, 2016, Hydro One cut down 29 mature trees in Toronto’s Robertson Davies Park. At a Sept. 28 community meeting, Hydro One committed to replacing the felled trees and making other improvements. In October 2016, Toronto council authorized staff to accept an in kind contribution from Hydro One valued at $200,000 for trees, shrubs, park furniture and other amenities. Council also authorized staff to work with Hydro One to seek the railway’s permission for a sound barrier beside the park.
At the most recent council meeting, Coun. Lisa Deacon asked Russell Township to identify woodlands and other natural areas that could become parks as the community grows. She said residents regularly tell her about trees being cleared ahead of development and that mature woodlands are hard to replace once they are gone.
Deacon wants the township to start talking to landowners and developers before subdivision plans are finalized. The idea is to keep some existing woods and other natural features as future parkland rather than wait until after they have been cleared.
Township staff suggested exploring the idea in the 2027 business plan. Mayor Mike Tarnowski said he was comfortable with that direction and checked that council and staff were as well. The discussion did not designate any land as parkland or introduce new restrictions on tree cutting. Jonathan Bourgon said staff would look into the idea. He said he was not aware of another municipality taking that approach.
